***
The Minister then started singing Hum us desh ke vasi hai jis desh main Ganga behti hai. That's when everyone realised the Minister had been living in his own fantasy world since 1960.
Wait wait wait! You see the whole country of the system is juxtapositioned by the haemoglobin in the atmosphere because you are a sophisticated rhetorician intoxicated by the exuberance of your own verbosity!
***
The Minister then started singing Hum us desh ke vasi hai jis desh main Ganga behti hai. That's when everyone realised the Minister had been living in his own fantasy world since 1960.

As the side bar attests, Wo hu cang long (aka Crouching tiger, hidden dragon) is one of our favourite movies. Quite a few great historical epics like this have come out of East Asia in recent years. And Hollywood has a rich tradition of historical epics (everyone has seen Charleton Heston trying to play a Hebrew in a couple of movies, but the real aficionados won’t settle for anything other than the silent version). Bollywood, in contrast, seems to have lagged behind. Yes there is the Grand Mughal, but that was in 1960. More recently, Bollywood has given us turkeys like this.
Brothers A-A-A often wondered about a Desi period epic, set some time in the post-Islam era to give all three of us a chance to appear. The Mughal Empire is a natural candidate for the setting. Brothers and sisters over at the adda also had similar ideas.
So what would our movie include?
1. A fortress would change hands, and someone would escape with their life.
2. Dushmans would chase someone across Desh.
3. A royal scandal would involve a famous diamond.
4. Complicated amorous entanglements would test the characters.
5. A Sufi saint would lead his followers in search of a golden land beyond the rivers.
6. Ideas would be tested in philosophical debates and battles involving imperial forces promising order and stability, free people resisting the empire and villains.
7. There would be nautch girls, elephants, snakes, jadu-tona, tantriks and tigers.
8. Someone would be switched at birth.
9. There would be a murder mystery.
10. It would be over three hours long.
Dear reader, watch these pages for more details (as they develop) about this grandest epic of them all.
You say you want a revolution, well you know, we all want to change the world — sang Lennon. But do revolutions really change the world? Or do they run out of steam, spiral and turn? Lennon wanted to be counted out when you’re talking about destruction. And much like an omelette can’t be made without breaking an egg, so with revolutions without violence and destruction.
When do you support a revolution? This is not a rhetorical question in Pakistan. But if a revolution sweeps away Musharraf, will that cure Pakistan’s ailment? I don’t worry that Musharraf will be replaced by mad mullahs or the ISI. Mad mullahs and ISI are already in power. A revolution will probably replace Musharraf with another general, much like how Yahya replaced Ayub in 1969. What will a revolution achieve then? Is it perhaps not better to cut a deal that allows Musharraf an exit strategy? Similar debates are raging in Bangladesh?
What is a revolution anyway? When the existing order collapses, and rival factions fight it out until the most organised/cruellest/luckiest one comes to power — isn’t that what the fellow travellers romanticise as a revolution? Isn’t that what happened in Russia in 1917 or Iran in 1979?
Lennon probably thought about revolutions this way. Gandhi definitely wasn’t a believer in this kind of revolution. His was all for internal revolution: the truth force and moral regeneration, and a good dump in the morning. This is why, when it turned violent in February 1922, Gandhi didn’t hesitate to call off the non-cooperation movement.
What would have happened if he had not? Would there have been a revolution, as defined above?
Probably not. The movement probably would have run out of steam. Gandhi’s promise of Swaraj in one year was already stale when the Chauri Chaura incident happened. It’s possible that had the movement continued, it would have just gradually degenerated. But what would have replaced it? Intifada in Palestine has been replaced by asymmetric war in the form of suicide bombing. Would we have witnessed something similar in Desh?
If that happened, how would the British have reacted? Perhaps they would have sought out an exit strategy. Perhaps they would have cut a deal with moderate leaders like Jinnah, Motilal Nehru and CR Das. Perhaps these leaders would have founded a genuine federal republic.
Perhaps it would have been so, or perhaps not.
Perhaps the asymmetric war would have been met by violent repression. Perhaps the British would have matched, the Japanese empire in terms of oppression. Perhaps the British and the Japanese would have become allies in Asia. Perhaps the counter-insurgency violence in Desh would have warmed the British to Hitler. Perhaps there would have been a London-Berlin Axis.
Perhaps it’s in such a bleak world brother A-A-A would have lived?
Amar Akbar Anthony have joined The War on Terror, and launched our own sophisticated pysch-ops programme. We begin by issuing an all-points alert for the sinister Mullah Omar. Alert follows: 


Posted by Amar and Akbar